TabletPC'Corner: Toute l'information des Tablet PC

Accueil

Matériel

Comparaison entre le HP Compaq 2710p et le FS Lifebook T2010

Écrit par Stéphane TORRES - HPClean

13-09-2007

Gottabemobile a publié un test pour le moins intéressant de la comparaison de deux Tablet PC très proches en spécifications techniques et en prix:

Le HP Compaq 2710p
Le Fujitsu Siemens Lifebook T2010 (non disponible en Europe)

Une video haute résolution de 25 minutes est disponible, mais de prime abord, elle ne permet pas de mettre en avant un vainqueur par rapport à un autre. Ce sont deux Tablet PC séduisants dont il faudra vérifier plus en avant les possibilités en terme d'autonomie avec leurs batteries hautes capacités respectives. Toujours est il que le poids est aussi très proche (1.6 kg et 1.8 avec la batterie haute capacité environ), et que l'écran du T2010 semble supérieur à celui du 2710p

J'aurais aimé voir le Portege R400 en plus, bien qu'il ne soit pas de même génération matérielle et dispose d'autres attraits comme un composant SlideShow frontal.

A voir de toute urgence: http://www.gottabemobile.com/FujitsuT2010VsHP2710pInkShowVideoReview.aspx

RM272UT sku of the 2710p ($1749)
A1T0J10304A30001 sku of the T2010 ( $1799 )

Spec	HP 2710p	Fujitsu T2010
Processor	1.2 ghz Core 2 Duo, U7600	1.2 ghz Core 2 Duo, U7600
Chipset	Mobile Intel® GM965	Intel^® 965GM + ICH8M
Memory	2 gb, max 4 gb, 667 mhz. Turbo memory not supported.	1 gb, max 4 gb, 533 mhz. 1gb Turbo memory support.
Harddrive	100 gb Smart PATA, 4200 rpm. Cannot be upgraded to 7200 rpm drives.	60 gb S-ATA, 5400 rpm. 2.5" drives, can be upgraded to 7200 rpm. SSD options available
Wireless	Intel 802.11a/b/g, draft N and Broadcom available in other models; Bluetooth 2.0	Intel^® Wireless WiFi Link 4965AGN (802.11a/b/g/draft-n) or Atheros Super AG; Bluetooth 2.0
Integrated WWAN	Not included in this model, but is available and can be upgraded later with either hs2300 HSDPA or 1x EVDO-A. 2710p comes with integrated WWAN antenna	No.
Screen	12.1 WXGA 1280 x 800; Anti-glare; 300:1 (typical) contrast ratio; 200 nit (typical) brightness; 0.204 mm pixel resolution; LED; ±80° Horizontal, ±80° Vertical (typical) viewing angles; right to left rotating directional hinge.	12.1" WXGA TFT LED back-lit enhanced indoor display with wide viewing angles; Bi-directional hinge; 0.204 dot pitch, >220 nits brightness Optional: 12.1" WXGA indoor/outdoor display with anti-reflective coating
Graphics	Mobile Intel Graphics Media Accelerator X3100, with up to 384 MB shared system memory Microsoft DirectX 9 capable	Mobile Intel^® GMA X3100 with Intel^® Clear Video Technology enabling DX10 and MPEG-2; Dynamic Video Memory Technology (DVMT) responds to application requirements and efficiently allocates the proper amount of system memory (up to 384 MB) for optimal graphics and system performance.
Resolution	Internal: 1280 x 800. External: up to 2048 x 1536 at 75 Hz, and lower resolutions at up to 100 Hz	Maximum internal display resolution: 1280 x 800, 16M colors; External monitor resolution: 1600 x 1200, 16M colors; Simultaneous display resolution: 1280 x 800
Digitizer	Active with digital pen and eraser	Active with digital pen and eraser
Ambient Light Sensor	Yes	Not sure. Will update if I learn more.
Camera	Integrated 2 MP ( 1600 x 1200 ) with business card scanning ( integrated slot to scan business card )	No
Keyboard light	Yes	No
Keyboard	101 / 102-key compatible keyboard, 19-mm x 19-mm key pitch, 2.5 mm stroke	84-key keyboard, 19mm key pitch, 3mm key stroke with spill-resistant; official specs say "touch pad with left, right", and scroll buttons. Pictures do not show touchpad, though.
Casing	Silver with brushed aluminum, rubberized back, magnetic latch.	Black, with felt on back. No latch.
Track Stick or Touch Pad	Track stick	Track stick
Programmable buttons, on screen buttons, etc	capacitive touch volume controls ( not on screen ); programmable button on side of screen; one capactive touch button programmable ( not on screen ). No on-screen programmable buttons	Yes, 5 on-screen buttons, several programmable.
Scroll buttons	No	Yes
Screen flush with casing	Yes	Maybe - hard to tell based on pictures.
Ports	Standard: 2 USB 2.0 1 IEEE 1394 1 microphone in 1 headphone/line-out 1 docking connector 1 battery connector Rear: 1 RJ-45 1 RJ-11 1 external VGA monitor 1 AC power	Two USB 2.0, IEEE 1394, External monitor/VGA, modem (RJ-11) on select models, Gigabit Ethernet (RJ-45), docking connector, headphone/line-out jack, and microphone/line-in jack
Slots	1 Express Card/54 1 secure digital (An optional Integrated Smart Card Reader is available and replaces the Type I/II PC card slot)	One Type I/II PCMCIA slot, 32-bit PC CardBus architecture; One Smart Card slot; One shared slot for Memory Stick^®, Memory Stick PRO™, or Secure Digital (SD) card
Built-in Optical Drive	No. Available with docking station.	No. Available with docking station.
Security	Integrated fingerprint reader, security password software	Integrated fingerprint reader, security password software
Battery	6-cell ( 44 WHr, rated for 3 - 5 hours ), 6-cell Ultra slim battery also available ( 46 Whr, rated for 3 - 5 hours ). Both batteries can be used together to get 9 - 10 hours. Ultra-slim battery can be charged in docking station without the need of the tablet. Ultra-slim battery attaches to bottom of 2710p, causing it to be a little thicker. See weights below.	6-cell (62.6 WHr), 9-cell ( 93.9 Whr, rated for 11 hours) battery also available. The best I can tell, either the 6-cell or the 9-cell can be used. 9-cell battery extends out front of the T2010 causing it to be a little wider. See weights below.
Weight	3.7 lb (1.68 kg). Ultra-slim battery weighs 1.24 lbs for total of 4.94 lbs for 6 - 10 hours with two batteries combined. 2710p is roughly 1 lb heavier with comparable or slightly less battery life. I'm getting about 9 hours on HP optimized setting.	3.52 lbs with 6-cell battery, additional .32 lbs with 9-cell battery for a total of 3.84 lbs with the 9 cell battery, rated 11 hours. I have not read of any real-world experience of that 11 hour battery, yet. Fujitsu is 1 lb lighter with comparable battery performance, though.
Dimensions	11.42 x 8.35 x 1.11 in (290.00 x 212.00 x 28.20 mm)	11.9" x 8.8" x 1.36";
Warranty	3 year	1 year - additional warranties available for purchase
Price	$1749	$1799